‘It’s your fault’: Navy Federal Credit Union refuses to reimburse victims of Zelle fraud, class action lawsuits


A proposed class action lawsuit alleges that the Navy Federal Credit Union (NFCU) failed to protect and reimburse account holders who reported unauthorized transactions on Zelle, a popular money transfer service.

The 23-page complaint was filed by a Tennessee consumer who says the credit union refused to reimburse his account after a series of unauthorized Zelle transfers between January and April 2019 cost him $4,630.

According to the lawsuit, Navy Federal is aware that Zelle, which is integrated into banking apps and is believed to be the most widely used money transfer service in the country, “has become a favorite tool for fraudsters,” but has not sufficiently warned account holders to issue it or protect those who are victims of fraud. The case indicates that Plaintiff and other victims of Zelle imposters or scammers had their fraud claims wrongfully denied by Navy Federal because it is the credit union‘s practice to conduct inadequate investigations. and to “blame[] fraud victims for fraud.

“[W]When Zelle fraud victims turn to NFCU for help, NFCU has a simple, repeated, bad faith answer: It’s your fault, you’re on your own, and we won’t help. »

The lawsuit argues that Navy Federal’s failure to reimburse unauthorized Zelle transactions violates its contractual promise not to hold customers liable for fraudulent transfers that are reported in a timely manner. For example, the debit card disclosure in Navy Federal’s Zelle Terms and Conditions assures customers that “if you notify us of suspected fraud within 60 days of the statement date that the fraudulent transactions appear for the first time, we will not hold you responsible for confirmed fraudulent transactions.” The Navy Federal deposit agreement also promises that the credit union will fairly investigate reports of fraud, the case says.

According to the case, Navy Federal is evading its fraud protection promises by “unfairly and improperly” determining that fraudulent Zelle transactions are permitted. The claim alleges that Navy Federal disregarded definitions of unauthorized electronic funds transfers provided by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau and the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation which state that no fraudulent or fraud-induced transaction can be considered authorized. According to the case, Navy Federal’s alleged failure to properly investigate and reverse or refund account holders’ fraudulent Zelle transfers violates their rights under federal electronic funds transfer law.

Additionally, the filing argues that Navy Federal failed to take active steps to detect and prevent Zelle fraud despite promising to do so in its account documents, and failed to properly safeguard financial and account information. consumers against malicious third parties.

Plaintiff says that although he never signed up for Zelle, he discovered seven unauthorized Zelle transfers from his Navy Federal account and reported them to the credit union in July 2019. According to the lawsuit, Navy Federal issued the speculation that the fraud occurred because she linked the plaintiff’s old compromised debit card to a new checking account in 2018 after the man reported that his previous account had been compromised. Navy Federal suspected that “the fraudsters probably had [the plaintiff’s] prior information on the debit card “and had used them to make the Zelle transfers, relays the case.

According to the complaint, the plaintiff acted on his complaint three times and complied with instructions to submit a detailed written statement and contact Zelle. However, Navy Federal reportedly sent the complainant a letter in late July stating that “[b]After a thorough investigation of your account activity, we have determined that no errors have occurred. The letter further stated that the provisional credit of $4630.00 that had been applied to the plaintiff’s account would be canceled on July 25, the filing relays.

The lawsuit seeks coverage for anyone with a Navy Federal account who has reported one or more transfers from Zelle that they did not authorize to the Navy Federal Credit Union and suffered unreimbursed losses.

Get class action news delivered to your inbox – sign up for ClassAction.org’s free weekly newsletter here.

Previous Chase Freedom Flex Card: What Credit Score Do You Need?
Next How to refinance with bad credit